What is the rationale behind designating a terrestrial
species as endangered, threatened, or vulnerable in Newfoundland and
Labrador? According to the Endangered Species
Act (ESA), the designation of a species depends on the sensitivity to extinction
under current conditions if no management is implemented to conserve the
species1. Endangered species
face imminent danger to extirpation or extinction, threatened species are
likely to become endangered without management, and vulnerable species are
sensitive to human activities or natural events1. As such, without recovery planning (further elaborated
on in Recover Planning blog) these species are likely be pushed to the edge of
extinction.
As alluded to in our previous blog post, the Wolverine is
the only mammal in Newfoundland and Labrador that is listed as endangered. Though listed as endangered, the wolverine
may be regionally extirpated from its eastern range. There have been no verified reports of the
wolverine in Quebec since 1978 or in Labrador since 19502. However, the eastern Canadian population of
the wolverine continues to be listed as endangered instead of extirpated, mainly
due to yearly unconfirmed reports that indicate that the wolverine may still
persist in its Labrador range.
Figure 1. An image of two wolverine cubs. The
wolverine is listed as endangered under Newfoundland and Labrador's Species at
Risk Act. Photo Credit: Erwin & Peggy Bauer/Auscape International4
Despite the unconfirmed reports of wolverine sightings in
Labrador, the eastern wolverine population is highly susceptible to full
extirpation. Wolverines require large
expanses of undisturbed forest habitat to maintain viable numbers2. Unfortunately, due hunting and trapping,
declining caribou herds, and human encroachment on habitat2, the
wolverine population has plummeted.
Further, the wolverines low reproduction rate and low population density
limit the wolverines potential to recover2.
On a brighter note, the American Marten (or Newfoundland
Marten) shows potential signs of recovery since being listed as
threatened. The American marten is
highly susceptible to habitat loss and fragmentation due to forestry practices,
but since its listing under the ESA and Species at Risk Act (SARA), the marten
has shown increases in population numbers3. Reserves have been established in the Little
Grand Lake area to protect and recover the American marten, along with protection
within Terra Nova and Gros Morne National Parks. With provincial and federal protection
against harassment, capture, trade, and killing, the marten is likely to
recover to viable population numbers3.
Figure 3. The current range of the American Marten on insular Newfoundland. Photo Credit: Wildlife Division of Newfoundland and Labrador6
As we can see, the listing of a species may not always
lead to its recovery. The success of
threatened and endangered species requires not only legislative listing, but
the implementation of recovery planning.
Provincial and federal governments need to enforce legislation to take
measures to not just inventory all the endangered species, but to actually take
action in protecting and conserving endangered species.
For more information on Newfoundland and Labrador's Endangered Species Act, and the species currently listed under the act, see the links below.
Links:
Endangered Species Act: http://www.assembly.nl.ca/Legislation/sr/statutes/e10-1.htm#10_
Department of Environment and Conservation:
1 Endangered Species Act. 2001.
An act respecting the protection of endangered species. Retrieved on
March 2, 2012 at http://www.assembly.nl.ca/Legislation/sr/statutes/e10-1.htm#10_
2Species at Risk Public Registry. 2010.
Wolverine eastern population. Retrieved on March 2, 2012 at http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/species/speciesDetails_e.cfm?sid=137
3 Species at Risk Public Registry. 2010.
American Marten Newfoundland population.
Retrieved on March 2, 2012 at http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/species/speciesDetails
_e.cfm?sid=134
4 ARKive. 2012.
Images of life on Earth.
Retrieved on March 4, 2012 at http://www.arkive.org/wolverine/gulo-gulo/image-G114841.html
5 ARKive. 2012.
Images of life on Earth.
Retrieved on March 4, 2012 at http://www.arkive.org/american-marten/martes-americana/
6 Newfoundland
and Labrador Species at Risk. 2012. American Marten (Martes americana atrata).
Retireved on March 4, 2012 at http://www.env.gov.nl.ca/env/wildlife/ endangeredspecies/nf_marten.pdf
In the case of the marten it is shown, as we had seen in the class presentation on Terra Nova National Park, that coyotes may be of benefit to the recovery of Newfoundland Pine Marten due to alleviating predators (I.e. foxes). With that in mind has there been any estimates as to what proportion of the recovery is due to natural ecosystem interactions as opposed to established protected areas?
ReplyDeleteIt is difficult to quantify the proportion of recovery that is due to natural ecosystem interactions (e.g. coyotes alleviating the potential threat of foxes). There have been no formal studies as to estimate how much recovery is attributed to protected areas, but extrapolating from the Newfoundland Martens' primary threats, habitat loss and accidental capture, it may be possible to attribute a higher proportion of the species recovery being attributed to these protected areas. Granted, the Newfoundland Marten has large home ranges that may extend beyond these protected areas. However, actions to mitigate threats to the Newfoundland Marten are likely the most likely to aid in its recovery. As such, I would predict that Newfoundland Marten recovery is largely due to management efforts, whether within protected areas or otherwise, and that natural ecosystem interactions are playing a lesser role in the Newfoundland Martens' direct recovery.
DeleteIt's great to have a "good news story" about the Newfouldland Marten! But are there other species that have yet to be listed? How does our province compare to other provinces in listing species that may be at risk? How is the caribou doing these days? are they listed?
ReplyDeleteWe have attempted to answer some of your questions in subsequent blogs. We discuss how Newfoundland has failed to list many species, despite having been evaluated by the Species Status Advisory Committee (SSAC). Compared to some provinces, such as British Columbia, Newfoundland is doing well in that it actually has endangered species legislation, and aims to provide status reports and recovery plans for species at risk. However, compared to Ontario, there can still be some improvement in Newfoundland's actions to list species at risk.
DeleteAs for the Woodland Caribou, only the Labrador population has been listed under Newfoundland's ESA. In Labrador, a threatened status applies to sedentary caribou in Mealy Mountain, Red Wine, and Lac Joseph herds. However, on insular Newfoundland, the Woodland Caribou have not been designated as at risk. More information on the Woodland Caribou can be obtained from the species status report and recovery plans from the SARA Registry (http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/species/speciesDetails_e.cfm?sid=144).
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteComment shifted up in response to Dr. Hermanutz's comment.
Deletethis has been interesting to reed
ReplyDelete